Robbie and his daughter Lizabelle

Judge Craig McCarthy: Failing to Protect My Daughter from Sexual Abuse


As a parent, my primary duty is to ensure the safety and well-being of my child. Unfortunately, the judicial system, specifically Judge Craig McCarthy, has failed my daughter, Lizabelle, in the most critical ways. This blog post aims to shed light on the negligence and lack of response from Judge McCarthy, which has directly contributed to my daughter’s ongoing trauma and abuse.

A History of Neglect and Abuse

Following a trial, I was awarded majority time-sharing with Lizabelle. However, her mother, diagnosed with bipolar disorder, appealed the decision, which was dismissed. Despite this, she has made numerous unsubstantiated calls to the Department of Children and Families (DCF) and has kidnapped Lizabelle multiple times, taking her across the country to file false restraining orders against me—all of which were denied.

The Role of Judge McCarthy

In December, Judge McCarthy ordered Lizabelle’s return to me after a kidnapping incident but then mandated her return to her mother for winter break shortly thereafter. This decision was made despite the clear danger posed by her mother, who had previously shaved Lizabelle’s head and hidden her for ten months.

Currently, Lizabelle resides in Orlando with her mother and her uncle, who has sexually abused her. Despite filing motions months ago, including a request for a guardian ad litem and a petition for relocation, Judge McCarthy and his assistant have ignored my attempts to set a hearing. This negligence has led to another kidnapping incident, with the mother refusing to return Lizabelle as per the original court order and parenting plan.

Ignoring the Danger

Judge McCarthy has prohibited me from taking Lizabelle out of Florida, despite our court order and parenting plan stipulating our residence in San Diego. Lizabelle has attended six different schools in the past two years due to her mother’s repeated kidnappings and relocations. This instability has severely impacted her education and emotional well-being.

A Plea for Justice

I have exhausted my financial resources and am desperate for justice and protection for my daughter. Despite a court order and parenting plan, law enforcement and DCF have not provided assistance. Judge McCarthy’s orders have placed Lizabelle in a dangerous environment with her abuser, and my concerns about her safety have been consistently ignored.

Conclusion

Lizabelle is due to start school in less than two weeks, and her mother falsely claims custody, disregarding the court’s orders. Her attorney is complicit in this misinformation. I am losing faith in the court’s ability to protect my daughter and ensure her safety.

I urge anyone reading this to share our story and help us seek justice for Lizabelle. The judicial system must be held accountable for its failures, and Judge McCarthy must answer for the harm caused by his negligence.


Comments

2 responses to “Judge Craig McCarthy: Failing to Protect My Daughter from Sexual Abuse”

  1. Penelope Cruz Avatar
    Penelope Cruz

    WOW!? I’m so sorry that you are going through this. You must be so distraught. My son is going through a similar situation. You and your daughter look so happy in this picture. Is that the last time you saw her? My son hasn’t been able to see OR even speak to my granddaughter (his daughter) in 8 months and we also DON’T know the whereabouts due to a protective order. The courts are hostage takers in a battle during the war. And the children are POW’s. I really hope this all works out for you. Such corruption we have no days!

  2. Katie J Avatar
    Katie J

    Hi, after reading through this website, I am confused. Are there modification proceedings opened? I know I went through something similar, because both me and my ex are active military, and they told us that with modification proceedings, it’s the same as initial custody proceedings where there’s a standard order that the child has to remain in the state until a new final judgment is placed. When do you guys go to trial? Or are you still in discovery phase of exchanging information? Because you have a blog that says her attorney has her mandatory disclosure, so have you supplied yours?
    Your parenting plan is in San Diego, but your petition to relocate has not been heard? Where are you trying to go?
    This whole website reads in a very confusing manner. It seems like you should try talking with her or figuring it out in a courtroom instead of airing your dirty laundry for the world to see

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *